State-of-the-Art in Predicting the Added Resistance of Ship Advancing in Waves

doi:10.19423/j.cnki.31-1561/u.2023.03.001

Abstract

Abstract: Along with the advancement of the International Maritime Organization’s strategy on reducing greenhouse gas emissions, the prediction of added resistance in waves has become a hot issue during the last decade. As a second-order wave force, the mechanism of added resistance in waves is not only related to the characteristics of the ship itself, but also to its operating conditions and marine environment. However, the experimental determination and numerical prediction of the added resistance in waves have remained a challenge due to various technical constraints. This study briefly presents the state-of-the-art of various methods for the prediction of the added resistance in waves by reviewing and commenting the development of various methods, such as experimental methods, potential flow methods, viscous flow methods, semi-empirical methods and data-driven methods. In addition, based on a newly developed semi-empirical formula, a new type of contour diagram of the average added resistance for a ship sailing at various speeds under various sea states is presented to facilitate engineering applications. Finally, the prime concern of the future research is proposed based on thorough discussion.

Key words: added resistance in waves, seakeeping, semi-empirical formula, wave diffraction effect, numerical experiment, green shipping

摘要： 随着国际海事组织减少温室气体排放战略的稳步推进,波浪增阻预报成为近十多年来的热点研究课题之一。作为二阶波浪力,其成因既与船舶本身特征相关,又与其营运状态和海洋环境相关。由于存在各种限制,对其进行精确测定和数值预报均十分困难。该文阐述了各种波浪增阻预报方法的研究现状,包括实验方法、基于势流理论的方法、基于求解黏性方程的方法、半经验方法和数据驱动方法等,回顾和评述了各种方法的发展历程并展望了未来发展趋势;此外,基于半经验公式,文中展示了新型船舶各航速与各海况下的平均波浪增阻等值线图,该图表便于工程实践应用;最后,在充分讨论的基础上,提出了未来研究工作需重点关注的方向。

关键词: 波浪增阻, 船舶耐波性, 半经验公式, 绕射效应, 数值实验, 绿色航运

CLC Number:

U661.73

LIU Shukui. State-of-the-Art in Predicting the Added Resistance of Ship Advancing in Waves[J]. Ship & Boat, 2023, 34(03): 1-24.

刘树魁. 波浪增阻预报的研究现状与未来展望[J]. 船舶, 2023, 34(03): 1-24.

References

[1] Marine Environment Protection Committee.2018 guidelines on the method of calculation of the attained energy efficiency design index (EEDI) for new ships [EB/OL]. [2022-12-13]. https://wwwcdn.imo.org/localresources/en/KnowledgeCentre/IndexofIMOResolutions/MEPCDocuments/MEPC.308(73).pdf .
[2] Marine Environment Protection Committee.2021 guidelines on survey and certification of the attained energy efficiency existing ship index (EEXI)[EB/OL] . [2022-12-13]. https://wwwcdn.imo.org/localresources/en/KnowledgeCentre/IndexofIMOResolutions/MEPCDocuments/MEPC.334(76).pdf.
[3] Marine Environment Protection Committee.2021 guidelines on operational carbon intensity indicators and the calculation methods (CII guidelines, G1)[EB/OL]. [2022-12-13]. https://wwwcdn.imo.org/localresources/en/OurWork/Environment/Documents/Air%20pollution/MEPC.336(76).pdf.
[4] YANG K K, KIM Y.Numerical analysis of added resistance on blunt ships with different bow shapes in short waves[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Technology,2017(2): 245-258.
[5] 于海,封培元,熊小青,等. 中型豪华游船波浪增阻数值模拟分析[J]. 船舶, 2019(1): 99-104.
[6] 封培元,沈兴荣,范佘明,等. 超大型集装箱船全浪向波浪增阻预报技术研究[J]. 船舶, 2019(6): 109-115.
[7] 郝昊, 陈伟民, 李传庆, 等. 波浪增阻计算和船型优化[J]. 上海船舶运输科学研究所学报, 2019(1): 23-26, 32.
[8] International Towing Tank Conference. Recommended procedures and guidelines: 7.5-04-01-01, preparation, conduct and analysis of speed/power trials, revision 14[S]. Zurich: International Towing Tank Conference, 2021: 1-77.
[9] 冯松波,魏锦芳,王杉. 不同波浪增阻计算方法对实船航速修正影响的分析[J]. 中国造船, 2021(3): 214-221.
[10] LIU S, KOH C, NIKOLOPOULOS L, et al.Re-Analysis of Speed Trials for the Effect of Environmental Conditions[C] // Proceedings of the SNAME Maritime Convention, Houston, USA, 2022.
[11] Marine Environment Protection Committee. Guidelines for determining minimum propulsion power to maintain the manoeuvrability of ships in adverse conditions[EB/OL].[2022-12-13]. https://www.ccs.org.cn/ccswzen/articleDetail?id=202206220230725392&columnId=201900006000000013.
[12] 刁峰, 陈纪康, 陈京普, 等. 适用于最小推进功率评估的波浪增阻数值预报方法应用研究[J]. 水动力学研究与进展(A辑), 2020(6): 736-742.
[13] LIU S K, PAPANIKOLAOU A, SHANG B G.Regulating the safe navigation of energy-efficient ships:a critical review of the finalized IMO guidelines for assessing the minimum propulsion power of ships in adverse conditions[J] .Ocean Engineering, 2022, 249: 111011.
[14] HAVELOCK T H.The pressure of water waves upon a fixed obstacle[J]. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Mathematical and Physical Sciences,1940, 175: 409-421.
[15] BECK R, REED A.Modern seakeeping computations for ships[C] // Proceedings of the 23rd Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Val de Reuil, France, 2001.
[16] 朱仁传, 徐德康, 王慧, 等. 船舶耐波性近期研究进展与若干评述[J]. 船舶, 2022(3): 1-19.
[17] 魏锦芳, 陈京普, 周伟新. 考虑短波增阻的船舶失速系数(fw)计算方法研究[J]. 水动力学研究与进展, 2013(2): 144-150.
[18] LIU S K.Revisiting the influence of a ship’s draft on the drift force due to diffraction effect[J]. Ship Technology Research, 2020(3): 175-180.
[19] LIU S K, SHANG B G, PAPANIKOLAOU A.On the resistance and speed loss of full type ships in a seaway[J]. Ship Technology Research, 2019(3): 161-179.
[20] LIU S K, PAPANIKOLAOU A.Regression analysis of experimental data for added resistance in waves of arbitrary heading and development of a semi-empirical formula[J].Ocean Engineering, 2020, 206: 107357.
[21] NAKAMURA S.Collection of titles on domestic and foreign literature concerning of the resistance increase and propulsive performance in waves[J]. Bulletin of the Society of Naval Architects of Japan, 1975, 558: 598-607.
[22] UENO K, NAKAMURA J, SATOO N, et al.Some experiments of rolling effect on ahead resistance of ships[J]. Transactions of the West-Japan Society of Naval Architects, 1966, 31: 19-37.
[23] UENO K, NAKAMURA J, SATOO N, et al.Some experiments of heaving effect on ahead resistance of ships[J]. Transactions of the West-Japan Society of Naval Architects, 1969, 37: 277-298.
[24] UENO K, ONO I, TAKESHITA H, et al.Some experiments of pitching effect on ahead resistance of ships[J]. Transactions of the West-Japan Society of Naval Architects, 1969, 37: 257-276.
[25] International Towing Tank Conference. Report of seakeeping committee[R]. Zurich: International Towing Tank Conference, 1966: 418-432.
[26] STRØM-TEJSEN J, YEH H Y H, MORAN D D. Added resistance in waves[J]. Transactions of the Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers, 1973, 81: 109-143.
[27] LEE J H, KIM Y, KIM B S, et al.Comparative study on analysis methods for added resistance of four ships in head and oblique waves[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2021, 236: 109552.
[28] FUJII H, TAKAHASHI T.Experimental study on the resistance increase of a large full ship in regular oblique waves[C] //Proceeding of 14th ITTC, Ottawa, Canada, 1975.
[29] ADACHI H.On the calculation of wave exciting forces on ship translating in head sea waves[J]. Journal of the Society of Naval Architects of Japan, 1978(143): 34-40.
[30] FALTINSEN O M, MINSAAS K J, LIAPIS N.et al.Prediction of resistance and propulsion of a ship in a seaway[C] // Proceeding of 13th Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Tokyo, Japan, 1980: 505-529.
[31] STEEN S, FALTINSEN O M.Added resistance of a ship moving in small sea states[C]// Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Practical Design of Ships and Mobile Units, The Hague, The Netherlands, 1998.
[32] GUO B J, STEEN S.Evaluation of added resistance of KVLCC2 in short waves[J]. Journal of Hydrodynamics, SER. B, 2011(6): 709-722.
[33] KURODA M, TSUJIMOTO M, FUJIWARA T, et al.Investigation on components of added resistance in short waves[J]. Journal of the Japan Society of Naval Architects and Ocean Engineers, 2008(8): 171-176.
[34] TSUJIMOTO M, SHIBATA K, KURODA M, et al.A practical correction method for added resistance in waves[J]. Journal of the Japan Society of Naval Architects and Ocean Engineers, 2008(8): 177-184.
[35] OHKUSU H.Added resistance in waves in the light of unsteady wave pattern analysis[C] // Proceeding of 13th Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Tokyo, Japan, 1980.
[36] NAITO S, ZHANG J P.Research on unsteady wave field: wave pattern analysis with transverse cut method[J]. Journal of the Kansai Society of Naval Architects, 1990, 213: 31-42.
[37] KASHIWAGI M.Hydrodynamic study on added resistance using unsteady wave analysis[J]. Journal of Ship Research, 2013(4): 220-240.
[38] BLUME P, KRACHT A.Prediction of the behavior and propulsive performance of ships with bulbous bow in waves[J]. Transactions of the Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers, 1985, 93: 79-94.
[39] KADOMATSU K.Study on the required minimum output of main propulsion engine considering maneuverability in rough sea [D]. Yokohama: Yokohama National University, 1988.
[40] BLOK J J.The resistance increase of a ship in waves [D]. Delft: Delft University of Technology, 1993.
[41] KURODA M, TSUJIMOTO M, SASAKI N, et al.Development of STEP for the reduction of added resistance in waves[C] // Proceedings of the 22nd International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference, Rhodes, Greece, 2012.
[42] LARSSON L, STERN F, VISONNEAU M.Numerical ship hydrodynamics: an assessment of the gothenburg 2010 workshop[M]. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands, 2014.
[43] HINO T, STERN F, LARSSON L, et al.Numerical ship hydrodynamics: an assessment of the Tokyo 2015 workshop[M]. Cham: Springer, 2021.
[44] PARK D M, LEE J, KIM Y.Uncertainty analysis for added resistance experiment of KVLCC2 ship[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2015, 95: 143-156.
[45] VAN ESSEN S, LAFEBER W.Wave-induced current in a seakeeping basin[C] // Proceedings of the 36th OMAE Conference, Trondheim, Norway, 2017.
[46] VAN ESSEN S, SCHARNKE J, BUNNIK T, et al.Linking experimental and numerical wave modelling[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, 2020(3): 198.
[47] SOGIHARA N, TSUJIMOTO M, FUKASAWA R, et al.Uncertainty analysis for measurement of added resistance in short regular waves: its application and evaluation[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2020, 216: 107823.
[48] VALANTO P, HONG Y P.Experimental investigation on ship wave added resistance in regular head, oblique, beam, and following waves[C] // Proceedings of the 25th International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference, Kona, USA, 2015.
[49] VALANTO P, HONG Y.Wave added resistance and propulsive performance of a cruise ship in waves[C] // Proceedings of the 27th International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference, San Francisco, USA, 2017.
[50] YASUKAWA H, MATSUMOTO A, IKEZOE S.Wave height effect on added resistance of full hull ships in waves[J].Journal of the Japan Society of Naval Architects and Ocean Engineers, 2016, 23: 45-54.
[51] LIU S K, SPRENGER F, PAPANIKOLAOU A, et al.Experimental and numerical studies on linear and nonlinear seakeeping phenomena of the DTC ship in regular waves[J]. Ship Technology Research, 2021(1): 41-61.
[52] PAPANIKOLAOU A, ZARAPHONITIS G, BITNER-GREGERSEN E, et al.Energy efficient safe Ship operation (SHOPERA)[J]. Transportation Research Procedia, 2016, 14: 820-829.
[53] MARÓN A. SHOPERA deliverable D3.4: report on model tests at CEHIPAR[R]. 2016.
[54] GERHARDT F C, KJELLBERG M, KORKMAZ B, et al.Determining the EEDI minimum propulsion power[C] //
Proceedings of Influence of EEDI on Ship Design & Operation Online Conference, 2020: 1-15.
[55] FENG P Y, LIU S K, SHANG B G, et al.Minimum propulsion power assessment of a VLCC to maintain the maneuverability in adverse conditions[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, 2021(11): 1287.
[56] KASHIWAGI M, IWASHITA H, MIURA S, et al.Study on added resistance with measured unsteady pressure distribution on ship-hull surface[C] // Proceedings of the 34th Intl Workshop on Water Waves and Floating Bodies, Newcastle, Australia, 2019.
[57] IWASHITA H.Innovative measurement of unsteady pressure distribution on ship-hull surface and its use for hydrodynamic study on seakeeping[C] // Proceedings of the 33th Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Osaka, Japan, 2020.
[58] MARUO H.The excess resistance of a ship in rough seas[J]. International Shipbuilding Progress, 1957(35): 337-345.
[59] MARUO H.The drift of a body floating on waves[J]. Journal Ship Research, 1960(3): 1-10.
[60] GERRITSMA J, BEUKELMAN W.Analysis of the resistance increase in waves of a fast cargo ship[J]. International Shipbuilding Progress, 1972, 19: 285-293.
[61] SALVESEN N.Second-order steady state forces and moments on surface ships in oblique regular waves[C] // Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Dynamics of Marine Vehicles and Structures in Waves, London, 1974: 212-226.
[62] SALVESEN N, TUCK E O, FALTINSEN O.Ship motions and sea loads[J]. Transactions of the Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers, 1970, 78: 250-287.
[63] BOESE P.Eine einfache methode zur berechnung der widerstandserhöhung eines schiffes im seegang [R]. 1970.
[64] PINKSTER J A, VAN OORTMERSSEN G.Computation of the first and second order wave forces on bodies oscillating in regular waves[C] // Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Numerical Ship Hydrodynamics, Berkeley, USA, 1977: 136-159.
[65] PAPANIKOLAOU Α.Potential theory of second order for cylinders oscillating vertically[J]. Schiffstechnik, 1978, 25: 53-80.
[66] HIGO Y, HA M K.A study on added resistance of a restrained body with forward speed in waves[J]. Journal of the Society of Naval Architects of Japan, 1991(169): 75-83.
[67] 戴遗山, 黄德波. 船舶波浪增阻的近场和远场公式[J]. 哈尔滨船舶工程学院学报, 1994(1): 1-5.
[68] HEARN G E, TONG K C, LAU S M.Hydrodynamic models and their influence on added resistance predictions[C] // Proceedings of the Third International Symposium on Practical Design of Ships and Mobile Units, Trondheim, Norway, 1987.
[69] JONCQUEZ S, BINGHAM H, ANDERSEN P, et al.Validation of added resistance computations by a potential-flow boundary-element method[C]// Proceedings of the 27th Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Seoul, Korea, 2008.
[70] SHIGUNOV V, EL MOCTAR O, PAPANIKOLAOU A, et al.International benchmark study on numerical simulation methods for prediction of manoeuvrability of ships in waves[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2018, 165: 365-385.
[71] KIM K H, KIM Y.Numerical study on added resistance of ships by using a time-domain Rankine panel method[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2011(13): 1357-1367.
[72] KASHIWAGI M, IKEDA T, SASAKAWA T.Effects of forward speed of a ship on added resistance in waves[J]. International Journal of Offshore and Polar Engineering, 2010, 20: 196-203.
[73] LIU S K, PAPANIKOLAOU A, ZARAPHONITIS G.Practical approach to the added resistance of a ship in short waves[C]//Proceedings of the 25th International Ocean and Polar Engineering Conference, Kona, USA,2015.
[74] SONG X Y, ZHANG X S, BECK R F.Numerical study on added resistance of ships based on time-domain desingularized-Rankine panel method[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2022, 248: 110713.
[75] DUAN W Y, CHEN J K, ZHAO B B.Second-order Taylor expansion boundary element method for the second-order wave radiation problem[J]. Applied Ocean Research, 2015, 52: 12-26.
[76] DUAN W Y, LI J D, CHEN J K, et al.Time-domain TEBEM method for wave added resistance of ships with forward speed[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Technology, 2021(1): 174-189.
[77] SHAO Y L, FALTINSEN O M.Linear seakeeping and added resistance analysis by means of body-fixed coordinate system[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Technology, 2012(4): 493-510.
[78] CHEN X, ZHU R C, ZHOU W J, et al.A 3D multi-domain high order boundary element method to evaluate time domain motions and added resistance of ship in waves[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2018, 159: 112-128.
[79] IWASHITA H, OHKUSU M.The green function method for ship motions at forward speed[J]. Ship Technology Research, 1992(2): 3-21.
[80] PAPANIKOLAOU A, LIU S K.On the prediction of added resistance of ships in waves[C]//William Froude Conference: Advances in Theoretical and Applied Hydrodynamics-Past and Future, Portsmouth, UK, 2010.
[81] BECKER E.Das wellenbild einer unter der oberfläche eines stromes schwerer Flüssigkeit pulsierenden quelle[J]. ZAMM-Zeitschrift Für Angewandte Mathematik Und Mechanik, 1958, 38: 391-399.
[82] 缪国平, 刘应中. 船舶与海洋工程中的二阶波浪力理论[J]. 船舶工程, 1993(4): 15-26, 3.
[83] BUNNIK T.Seakeeping calculations for ships, taking into account the nonlinear steady waves[D]. Delft: Delft University of Technology, 1999.
[84] BUNNIK T, VAN DAALEN E, KAPSENBERG G, et al.A comparative study on state-of-the-art prediction tools for seakeeping[C] //Proceedings of 28th Symposium on Naval hydrodynamics, Pasadena, USA, 2010: 242-255.
[85] NAITO S, YAMANOTO O, TAKAHASHI T.Effect of ship hull forms on resistance increase in waves[C] // Proceedings of the Fifth Marine Dynamics Symposium, Tokyo, Japan, 1988: 45-79.
[86] NAITO S.Propulsive performance of ships in actual seas[C] // Proceedings of Seventh Osaka Colloquium on Seakeeping and Stability, Osaka, Japan, 2008.
[87] LARSSON L.CFD in ship design-prospects and limitations[J]. Ship Technology Research, 1997(3): 133-154.
[88] WILSON R, PATERSON E, STERN F.Unsteady RANS CFD for naval combatants in waves[C] // Proceedings of the 22nd Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Washington, USA, 1998:532-549.
[89] SATO Y, MIYATA H, SATO T.CFD simulation of 3-dimensional motion of a ship in waves: application to an advancing ship in regular heading waves[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Technology, 1999(3): 108-116.
[90] HOCHBAUM A C, VOGT M.Towards the simulation of seakeeping and manoeuvring based on the computation of the free surface viscous ship flow[C] // Proceedings of the 24th symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Fukuoka, Japan, 2002: 268-281.
[91] HINO T, GIJUTSU K, KENKYŪJO A. Proceedings of CFD workshop Tokyo 2005[C]. Tokyo: National Maritime Research Institute, 2005.
[92] ORIHARA H, MIYATA H.Evaluation of added resistance in regular incident waves by computational fluid dynamics motion simulation using an overlapping grid system[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Technology, 2003(2): 47-60.
[93] SIMONSEN C, OTZEN J, JONCQUEZ S, et al.EFD and CFD for KCS heaving and pitching in regular head waves[J] . Proceedings of the 27th Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Seoul, Korea, 2008.
[94] DENG G B, QUEUTEY P, Visonneau M.Seakeeping prediction for a container ship with RANS computation[C] // Proceeding of the 22nd Chinese Conference in Hydrodynamics, Chengdu, China, 2009: 1-16.
[95] ORIHARA H.Comparison of CFD simulations with experimental data for a tanker model advancing in waves[J]. International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, 2011(1): 1-8.
[96] DENG G B, QUEUTEY P, VISONNEAU M.RANS prediction of the KVLCC2 tanker in head waves[J]. Journal of Hydrodynamics, Ser. B, 2010(5): 476-481.
[97] GUO B J, STEEN S, DENG G B.Seakeeping prediction of KVLCC2 in head waves with RANS[J]. Applied Ocean Research, 2012, 35: 56-67.
[98] SADAT-HOSSEINI H, WU P C, CARRICA P M, et al.CFD verification and validation of added resistance and motions of KVLCC2 with fixed and free surge in short and long head waves[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2013, 59: 240-273.
[99] SIMONSEN C D, OTZEN J F, JONCQUEZ S, et al.EFD and CFD for KCS heaving and pitching in regular head waves[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Technology, 2013(4): 435-459.
[100] SHEN Z R, WAN D C.RANS computations of added resistance and motions of a ship in head waves[J]. International Journal of Offshore and Polar Engineering, 2013(4): 264-271.
[101] SIGMUND S, EL MOCTAR O.Numerical and experimental investigation of added resistance of different ship types in short and long waves[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2018, 147: 51-67.
[102] CHEN S, HINO T, MA N, et al.RANS investigation of influence of wave steepness on ship motions and added resistance in regular waves[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Technology, 2018(4): 991-1003.
[103] KOBAYASHI H, KUME K, ORIHARA H, et al.Parametric study of added resistance and ship motion in head waves through RANS: calculation guideline[J].Applied Ocean Research, 2021, 110: 102573.
[104] HOCHKIRCH K, MALLOL B.On the importance of full-scale CFD simulations for ships[C] // Proceedings of the 12th Conference of Computer and IT Applications in the Maritime Industries (COMPIT), Cortona, Italy, 2013: 85-95.
[105] TEZDOGAN T, DEMIREL Y K, KELLETT P, et al.Full-scale unsteady RANS CFD simulations of ship behaviour and performance in head seas due to slow steaming[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2015, 97: 186-206.
[106] SHIFRIN L S.An approximate calculation of added resistance of ship in regular waves[J]. Sudostroenie, 1973, 12: 5-7.
[107] JINKINE V, FERDINANDE V.A method for predicting the added resistance of fast cargo ships in head waves[J]. International Shipbuilding Progress, 1974, 238: 149-167.
[108] NETSVETAEV Y A.An approximation for calculating the additional resistance of a ship in rough seas
[C] // Proceedings of International Symposium on Ship Hydrodynamics and Energy Saving, El Pardo, 1983.
[109] International Towing Tank Conference. Recommended procedures and guidelines: 7.5-04-01-01.2. full scale measurements speed and power trials analysis of speed/power trial data[S]. Zurich: International Towing Tank Conference, 2005: 1-11.
[110] International Towing Tank Conference. Specialist committee on performance of ships in service: final report and recommendations to the 27th ITTC[R]. 2014.
[111] LIU S K, PAPANIKOLAOU A.Fast approach to the estimation of the added resistance of ships in head waves[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2016, 112: 211-225.
[112] LIU S K, PAPANIKOLAOU A.Approximation of the added resistance of ships with small draft or in ballast condition by empirical formula[J]. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part M: Journal of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, 2019(1): 27-40.
[113] LIU S K, PAPANIKOLAOU A.Regression analysis of experimental data for added resistance in waves of arbitrary heading and development of a semi-empirical formula[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2020, 206: 107357.
[114] URSELL F.The effect of a fixed vertical barrier on surface waves in deep water[J]. Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 1947(3): 374-382.
[115] TAKAHASHI T.A practical prediction method of added resistance of a ship in waves and its application to hull form design[J]. Transactions of the West-Japan Society of Naval Architects, 1988, 75: 75-95.
[116] MOURKOGIANNIS D, LIU S K.Investigation of the influence of the main dimensional ratios of a ship on the added resistance and drift force in short waves[C] // Proceedings of the 31st International Ocean and Polar Engineering Conference, Rhodes, Greece, 2021.
[117] SÖYLEMEZ M, GÖREN Ö. Diffraction of oblique waves by thick rectangular barriers[J] . Applied Ocean Research, 2003(6): 345-353.
[118] DUAN W Y, LI C Q.Estimation of added resistance for large blunt ship in waves[J] . Journal of Marine Science and Application, 2013(1): 1-12.
[119] KWON Y J.The effect of weather, particularly short sea waves, on ship speed performance [D]. Newcastle: Newcastle University, 1981.
[120] OGIWARA S, YAMASHITA S.On resistance increase in waves of short wavelength[J]. Journal of the Kansai Society of Naval Architects, 1996, 225: 37-45.
[121] SAKAMOTO T, BABA E.Minimisation of resistance of slowly moving full hull forms in short waves[C]//Proceedings of 16th Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Berkeley, USA, 1986: 598-612.
[122] NAITO S, NAKAMURA S, NISHIGUCHI A.Added resistance in regular head waves of a ship with blunt bow[C]//Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium on Practical Design of Ships and Mobile Units, Trondheim, Norway, 1987: 291-301.
[123] Kalske S.Unsteady bow wave field and added resistance of ships in short waves[C] //Proceedings of the 13th International Workshop on Water and Floatings Bodies, Alphen aan den Rijn, The Netherlands, 1998.
[124] YANG K K, KIM Y, JUNG Y W.Enhancement of asymptotic formula for added resistance of ships in short waves[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2018, 148: 211-222.
[125] CEPOWSKI T.The prediction of ship added resistance at the preliminary design stage by the use of an artificial neural network[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2020, 195: 106657.
[126] MARTIĆ I, DEGIULI N, MAJETIĆ D, et al.Artificial neural network model for the evaluation of added resistance of container ships in head waves[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, 2021(8): 826.
[127] DUAN W Y, YANG K, HUANG L M, et al.A DFN-based method for fast prediction of ships’ added resistance in heading waves[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2022, 245: 110484.
[128] KIM Y R, STEEN S.Application of machine learning algorithms for predicting added resistance in arbitrary wave headings of a ship[C]//Proceedings of ASME 2022 41st International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering, Hamburg, Germany, 2022.
[129] MITTENDORF M, NIELSEN U D, BINGHAM H B,et al.Towards the uncertainty quantification of semi-empirical formulas applied to the added resistance of ships in waves of arbitrary heading[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2022, 251: 111040.
[130] International Towing Tank Conference. The specialist committee on waves final report and recommendations to the 23rd ITTC[R]. 2016.
[131] International Towing Tank Conference. Report of the specialist committee on ships in operation at sea-final report and recommendations to the 29th ITTC [R]. 2021.
[132] MATSUMOTO K, HIROTA K, TAKAGISHI K.Development of energy saving bow shape at sea[C] // Proceedings of Osaka Colloquium on Seakeeping Performance of Ships, Osaka, Japan, 2000: 479-485.
[133] ORIHARA H, TSUJIMOTO M.Performance prediction of full-scale ship and analysis by means of on-board monitoring. part 2: validation of full-scale performance predictions in actual seas[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Technology, 2018(4): 782-801.
[134] LIU S K, LOH M, LEOW W, et al.Rational processing of monitored ship voyage data for improved operation[J]. Applied Ocean Research, 2020, 104: 102363.
[135] GUO B, ROGNEBAKKE O, TVETE H A, et al.Setting the Standard for Evaluation of In-Service Technical Ship Performance[C] // Proceedings of the 6th Hull Performance & Insight Conference, Tullamore, Ireland, 2021.
[136] Seakeeping Committee of the International Towing Tank Conference. Comparison of results obtained with compute programs to predict ship motions in six degrees-of-freedom and associated responses[C] // Proceedings of 15th ITTC, 1978: 79-92.
[137] KIM Y.Comparative study on linear and nonlinear ship motion and loads[C] // Proceedings of ITTC Workshop on Seakeeping-V & V for Non-linear Seakeeping Analysis, Seoul, Korea, 2010.
[138] WANG J B, BIELICKI S, KLUWE F, et al.Validation study on a new semi-empirical method for the prediction of added resistance in waves of arbitrary heading in analyzing ship speed trial results[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2021, 240: 109959.