Review of Influencing Factors of Ship Collision Damage

doi:10.19423/j.cnki.31-1561/u.2023.03.044

Abstract

Abstract: The factors affecting the ship collision damage have been attracting attention in order to reduce the impact of ship collision damage, enhance the safety of ship navigation and protect the water environment. The main influencing factors of the ship collision damage are reviewed from three aspects, including the impact of the bow, side structure of the collided ship and relative motion state of the two ships. The countermeasures and suggestions for reducing the ship collision damage are elaborated from three viewpoints including the optimization of the bow design, the strengthening of the side hull structure and the emergency operation, and the existing shortcomings are pointed out. Further research prospects for the ship collision damage are proposed, such as the coordination of the buffer bow, the crashworthiness enhancement and ship weight increase, and the interrelationship between the emergency operation and insufficient helmsman capabilities.

Key words: ship, collision damage, influencing factor, side structure strength, emergency operation

摘要： 为减少船舶碰撞损伤的影响、增强船舶航行安全性、保护水面环境,船舶碰撞损伤影响因素受到关注。该文从撞击船首、被撞船舷结构以及两船的相对运动状态等3个方面对船舶碰撞损伤主要影响因素进行综述。从优化船首设计、增强船舷结构强度和驾驶船舶应急操作3个角度阐述减少船舶碰撞损伤的对策建议,指出其中存在的不足,并提出下一步船舶碰撞损伤研究展望：协调缓冲船首刚度与变形度、提高船舶耐撞性与增加船体结构质量,及应急操作与舵手能力不足之间的相互关系。

关键词: 船舶, 碰撞损伤, 影响因素, 舷侧结构强度, 研究综述

CLC Number:

U661.4

ZHU Yuepeng, ZHOU Likun, GONG Fangyuan, JIAO Yuping. Review of Influencing Factors of Ship Collision Damage[J]. Ship & Boat, 2023, 34(03): 44-52.

朱跃鹏, 周利坤, 龚方圆, 焦玉萍. 船舶碰撞损伤影响因素研究综述[J]. 船舶, 2023, 34(03): 44-52.

References

[1] 王自力,顾永宁.船舶碰撞动力学过程的数值仿真研究[J]. 爆炸与冲击, 2001(1): 29-34.
[2] WOISIN G.Design against collision[J]. Advances in Marine Technology, 1979: 309-336.
[3] ITO H, KONDO K, YOSHIMURA N, et al.A simplified method to analyse the strength of double hulled structures in collision[J]. Journal of the Society of Naval Architects of Japan, 1984(156):283-296.
[4] PAIK J K, PEDERSEN P T.Modeling of the internal mechanics in ship collisions[J]. Ocean Engeering, 1996(2):107-142.
[5] HOGSTRÖM P, RINGSBERG J W. An extensive study of a ship’s survivability after collision-A parameter study of material characteristics, non-linear FEA and damage stability analyses(Article)[J]. Marine Structures, 2012(1): 1-28.
[6] HARIS S, AMDAHL J.Analysis of ship-ship collision damage accounting for bow and side deformation interaction[J]. Marine Structures, 2013, 32: 18-48.
[7] HARIS S, AMDAHL J.An analytical model to assess a ship side during a collision[J]. Ships and Offshore Structures, 2012(4):431-448.
[8] KO Y G, KIM S J, PAIK J K.Effects of a deformable striking ship’s bow on the structural crashworthiness in ship-ship collisions[J]. Ships and Offshore Structures, 2018(Sup. 1):228-250.
[9] ABUBAKAR A, DOW R S.The impact analysis characteristics of a ship’s bow during collisions.[J]. Engineering Failure Analysis, 2019, 100: 492-511.
[10] HOGSTRÖM P, RINGSBERG J. Assessment of the crashworthiness of a selection of innovative ship structures[J]. Ocean Engineering, 2013, 59: 58-72.
[11] PRABOWO A R, BAE D M, SOHN J M, et al.Analysis of structural damage on the struck ship under side collision scenario[J]. Alexandria Engineering Journal, 2018(3): 1761-1771.
[12] PRABOWO A R, SOHN J M, BAE D M, et al.Investigating crashworthy single and double skin structures against accidental ship-to-ship interaction[J]. Curved and Layered Structures, 2018(1): 180-189.
[13] MINORSKY V U.An analysis of ship collisions with reference to protection of nuclear powerplants[J]. Journal of Ship Research, 1959(2):1-4.
[14] KITAMURA O.FEM approach to the simulation of collision and grounding damage[J]. Marine Structures, 2002(4):403-428.
[15] TABRI K, MÄÄTTÄNEN J, RANTA J. Model-scale experiments of symmetric ship collisions[J]. Journal of Marine Science and Technology, 2008(1): 71-84.
[16] PRABOWO A R, BAE D M, SOHN J M, et al.Evaluating the parameter influence in the event of a ship collision based on the finite element method approach[J].International Journal of Technology, 2016(4): 592-602.
[17] PRABOWO A R, BAE D M, SOHN J M, et al.Energy behavior on side structure in event of ship collision subjected to external parameters[J]. Heliyon, 2016(11):192.
[18] PRABOWO A R, MUTTAQIE T, JUNG M S, et al.Nonlinear analysis of inter-island RoRo under impact: effects of selected collision’s parameters on the crashworthy double-side structures[J]. Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering, 2018 (5):248.
[19] PRABOWO A R, LAKSONO F B, SOHN J M.Investigation of structural performance subjected to impact loading using finite element approach: case of ship-container collision[J]. Curved and Layered Structures, 2020(1):17-28.
[20] 刘敬喜, 胡紫剑, 叶文兵. 柔性、刚性球艏对双壳舷侧结构耐撞性能影响的研究[J].中国舰船研究, 2008(5):32-36.
[21] 胡宗文,刘昆,王自力.撞击船艏刚度对船体结构碰撞性能影响[J].振动与冲击, 2014(14): 149-154.
[22] 刘昆, 张延昌, 王自力. 船首形状对舷侧结构碰撞性能的影响研究[J]. 船舶工程, 2010(2):13-16, 31.
[23] LIU W G, LIU J X, ZHANG M.Experimental and numerical analysis of single side ship structure laterally punched by different indenters[C]//Proceedings of the 28th International Ocean and Polar Engineering Conference, Sapporo, Japan, 2018.
[24] LIU B, CHEN L, LIAO X T, et al.Finite element analysis of a container ship struck by rigid and deformable bows(Conference Paper)[C]//Proceedings of ASME 37th International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering, Madrid, Spain, 2018.
[25] 王自力, 顾永宁. 双层舷侧结构碰撞损伤过程研究[J]. 船舶工程, 2000(1):17-20, 3.
[26] 肖桃云,王涛.三峡库区船舶碰撞能量损失方法的研究[J].中国舰船研究, 2008(5):25-31.
[27] 崔濛, 刘敬喜, 龚榆峰, 等.帽型加筋结构耐撞性能试验与仿真研究[C]//奋发图强圆梦海疆——中国造船工程学会船舶力学学术委员会第八次全体会议文集, 大连, 2014:373-384.
[28] 彭正梁,杨磊,费宝祥.高强钢船体板架落锤冲击试验及数值仿真[J].中国舰船研究, 2018(增刊1):100-105.
[29] 姚鹏. 碰撞载荷下SPS船体结构响应与优化分析[D].镇江:江苏科技大学, 2021.
[30] 王自力, 顾永宁. 撞击参数对双层舷侧结构碰撞响应的影响[J].船舶工程, 2000(6):13-16.
[31] ZHANG J R, XIE Y H.Collision numerical simulation research of river-sea ship[J]. The Open Mechanical Engineering Journal, 2014(1): 885-891.
[32] 刘昆,王自力,张延昌, 等.基于全耦合技术的船体结构碰撞性能研究[J].船舶力学, 2015(5): 574-581.
[33] WANG Z P, LIU K, CHEN G, et al.An analytical method to assess the structural responses of ship side structures by raked bow under oblique collision scenarios[J]. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part M: Journal of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, 2021(3):773-791.
[34] 詹蓉, 崔濛, 曾佳, 等. 船舶抗碰撞性能研究[J].船舶工程, 2020(7):50-54.
[35] ENDO H, YAMADA Y, KITAMURA O.Experimental study on the buffer bow structures[C]//Proceedings of the Eighth. International Symposium on Practiconal Design of Ships and Other Floating Structures, Shanghai, China, 2001.
[36] KITAMURA O.Buffer bow design for the improved safety of ships[C]//SSC/SNAME/ASNE Symposium, 2000.
[37] YAGI S, KUMAMOTO H, MURAGISHI O, et al.A study on collision buffer characteristic of sharp entrance angle bow structure.[J]. Marine Structures, 2009(1): 12-23.
[38] 江华涛, 顾永宁. 高强度钢缓冲型船艏研究[J].船舶工程, 2003(1):12-17.
[39] 江华涛, 顾永宁. 船舶碰撞缓冲型球鼻艏概念探讨——球鼻曲率对碰撞的影响[J].中国造船, 2003(2):25-32.
[40] 江华涛, 顾永宁. 船艏横向框架对船艏碰撞性能的影响[J]. 上海交通大学学报, 2003(7):981-984.
[41] 李松. 缓冲型船球艏结构研究与分析[D]. 武汉: 武汉理工大学, 2011.
[42] PAIK J K, CHUNG J Y, CHOE I H, et al.On rational design of double hull tanker structures against collision[J]. Transactions-Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers, 1999(1):323-363.
[43] LUDOLPHY H.The unsinkable ship-development of the Y-shape support web[C]//Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Collision and Grounding of Ships, Copenhagen, Denmark, 2001.
[44] LEE J W, PETERSHAGEN H, RORUP J, et al.A New Concept of Energy Absorbing System for the Double Hull Tanker[J]. Journal of Ship and Ocean Technology, 1999(3): 12-26.
[45] BROWN K.Electricity storage as hydrogen stored in rechargeable slurry[C]//BIT’s 2nd Low Carbon Earth Summit-2012, Guangzhou, China, 2012: 307.
[46] LEHMANN E, PESCHMANN J.Energy absorption by the steel structure of ships in the event of collisions[J]. Marine Structures, 2002(4): 429-441.
[47] 王自力, 张延昌. 基于夹层板的单壳船体结构耐撞性设计[J]. 中国造船, 2008(1): 60-65.
[48] 王自力, 姜金辉. 一种基于内充泡沫塑料薄壁方管的单壳舷侧耐撞结构[J].中国造船, 2004(2): 51-56.
[49] 蔺晓红, 王敏.新型舷侧防护结构耐撞性能研究[J].船海工程, 2013(1): 9-13.
[50] 李慧, 张磊, 甘浪雄, 等.舷侧圆管式夹层板结构耐撞性能优化设计[J]. 船舶工程, 2016(4):51-55, 85.
[51] 黄颖,李丽娜,李国定,等.紧迫危险下减小碰撞损失的操船方法[J].大连海事大学学报, 2013(3): 17-21.
[52] 刘亚宾. 减小碰撞损失的操船方案[D]. 厦门: 集美大学, 2015.
[53] 李慧, 甘浪雄, 张磊, 等. 船舶碰撞损伤临界态势界定研究[J]. 船舶力学, 2020(3):380-389.